Dialectica Open the atlas

Continental · 1844–1900

Friedrich Nietzsche

German philologist who diagnosed the death of God

Friedrich Nietzsche
Friedrich Hermann Hartmann · Public domain · Commons ↗

Nietzsche argued that once belief in God collapses, the values built on it lose their ground; he traced morality’s origins to resentment and the will to power, and called for a revaluation of values that affirms life.

Life and thought

Friedrich Nietzsche (1844–1900), a Lutheran pastor’s son, became professor of classical philology at Basel at only 24. Ill health forced him to resign in 1879, and for a decade he moved between Swiss and Italian resorts, writing book after book that sold few copies. He collapsed mentally in Turin in January 1889 and never recovered; his sister later edited his notes and steered his reputation towards the German nationalism and antisemitism he had despised.

Nietzsche asked what follows once “God is dead”, that is, once belief in God can no longer ground European values. In On the Genealogy of Morality he argued that Christian morality grew from the resentment of the weak, who renamed the strong “evil” and their own weakness “good”. He saw life as will to power, imagined the Übermensch as one who creates values, and offered eternal recurrence as a test: could you will your life again, exactly as it was? Existentialists, Heidegger, Foucault and Deleuze all read him closely.

Works

1883Thus Spoke Zarathustra
1886Beyond Good and Evil
1887On the Genealogy of Morality

Shaped by

1788–1860Arthur SchopenhauerNietzsche found Schopenhauer’s main work in a Leipzig bookshop in 1865 and was overwhelmed by it.c. 535–475 BCEHeraclitusRiddling sage of Ephesus who saw the world as ordered flux1632–1677Baruch SpinozaIn an 1881 postcard Nietzsche hailed Spinoza as his “precursor”.

Shaped

1913–1960Albert CamusAlgerian-born French writer of the absurd and of revolt1926–1984Michel FoucaultFoucault modelled his “genealogy” on Nietzsche’s.1925–1995Gilles DeleuzeNietzsche and Philosophy (1962) read Nietzsche as the great anti-dialectician.1900–1990Nishitani KeijiKyoto School thinker of nihilism and emptiness

Argued against

c. 470–399 BCESocratesNietzsche blamed Socrates for putting cold reason above tragic instinct.

Criticised by

1929–2025Alasdair MacIntyreAfter Virtue frames modern ethics as a choice: “Nietzsche or Aristotle?”, and argues for Aristotle.

Meanwhile, in other traditions

1839–1914Charles Sanders PeirceLogician and scientist who founded pragmatism and semiotics1842–1910William JamesPsychologist and philosopher who made pragmatism famous1848–1925Gottlob FregeJena mathematician who invented modern logic1859–1952John DeweyPhilosopher of education and democracy; lectured in China 1919–211863–1902Swami VivekanandaMonk who introduced Vedānta and yoga to the West1869–1948Mohandas K. GandhiLeader of Indian independence and theorist of non-violent resistance