Dialectica Open the atlas

Early modern Europe · 1632–1677

Baruch Spinoza

Dutch lens-grinder, expelled by his synagogue, who equated God with Nature

Baruch Spinoza
anonymous · Public domain · Commons ↗

There is only one substance, “God or Nature”, and everything follows from it with necessity; mind and body are two aspects of one thing. Freedom is not escape from necessity but understanding it, which releases us from bondage to the passions.

Life and thought

Baruch (Benedictus) de Spinoza was born in Amsterdam to a family of Portuguese Jewish merchants. In 1656 the city’s synagogue issued a herem, a writ of expulsion, against him for “abominable heresies”. He lived modestly, grinding lenses for microscopes and telescopes, corresponded with scientists, and turned down a professorship at Heidelberg to keep his freedom. His Theological-Political Treatise came out anonymously in 1670 and was widely banned; his Ethics appeared only after his death in 1677.

The Ethics is set out like geometry, with definitions, axioms and proofs. Its conclusion is that there is only one substance, infinite and the cause of itself — “God or Nature” — and that minds and bodies are its finite modes, one and the same thing seen under thought or under extension. Everything follows necessarily; nature has no purposes and we have no free will in the usual sense. Freedom means understanding the causes of our emotions, which turns passive passions into active joy. Branded an atheist for a century, he was rediscovered by the German idealists, and Novalis called him a “God-intoxicated man”.

Works

1670Theological-Political Treatise
1677Ethics

Shaped by

1596–1650René DescartesThe only book Spinoza published under his own name was an exposition of Descartes’ Principles (1663).1588–1679Thomas HobbesEnglish materialist who grounded the state in fear and consent

Shaped

1775–1854Friedrich Wilhelm Joseph SchellingGerman idealist philosopher of nature, art and freedom1770–1831Georg Wilhelm Friedrich HegelGerman philosopher of spirit, history and dialectic1844–1900Friedrich NietzscheIn an 1881 postcard Nietzsche hailed Spinoza as his “precursor”.1768–1834Friedrich SchleiermacherBerlin theologian and translator of Plato, father of modern hermeneutics1925–1995Gilles DeleuzeFrench philosopher of difference, desire and becoming

Argued against

1138–1204Maimonides (Moses ben Maimon)The Theological-Political Treatise rejects Maimonides’ method of reading scripture so that it agrees with philosophy.

Criticised by

1646–1716Gottfried Wilhelm LeibnizLeibniz met Spinoza at The Hague in 1676 and spent years resisting his necessitarian monism.

Meanwhile, in other traditions

c. 1571–1636Mullā ṢadrāSafavid philosopher of Shiraz, founder of Transcendent Theosophy