Dialectica Open the atlas

China & East Asia · 1139–1193

Lu Jiuyuan (Lu Xiangshan)

Song scholar who taught that the mind is principle

“The universe is my mind, and my mind is the universe”: moral principle is complete in the original mind, so learning means first “establishing the great root” rather than fragmented study. He left mainly letters and recorded sayings.

Life and thought

Lu Jiuyuan, from a large and learned family in Jiangxi, passed the highest examination in 1172 and served in several posts, but is remembered as a teacher, above all at Elephant Mountain, which gave him his name Xiangshan. In 1175 the scholar Lü Zuqian brought him and Zhu Xi together at Goose Lake Temple to settle their differences; instead the meeting fixed them. Lu mocked Zhu’s method in a poem as “fragmented”, against his own “simple and easy” way. He died in 1193 while serving as magistrate of Jingmen.

As a boy, his chronology says, he wrote: “The universe is my mind, and my mind is the universe.” Moral principle is not something to be gathered from outside, book by book and thing by thing; it is already complete in the original mind that every person shares with the sages. Learning therefore means first “establishing what is great”, a phrase from Mencius, by turning back to that mind; once one knows the root, he said, “the Six Classics are my footnotes”. Wang Yangming revived his teaching three centuries later, and the school is called Lu–Wang after them.

Shaped by

c. 372–289 BCEMenciusLu said his learning came from reading Mencius for himself.1032–1085Cheng HaoElder Cheng brother, teacher of humaneness as oneness

Shaped

1472–1529Wang YangmingMing official, general and master of the School of Mind

Argued against

1130–1200Zhu XiThey debated method at Goose Lake Temple in 1175: Zhu’s broad study against Lu’s “simple and easy” return to the mind.

Meanwhile, in other traditions

1079–1142Peter AbelardParis logician famed for his dialectic and his love for Héloïsec. 1105–1185Ibn ṬufaylAndalusian court physician and philosophical novelist1126–1198Ibn Rushd (Averroes)Córdoban judge, known in Europe simply as “the Commentator”1138–1204Maimonides (Moses ben Maimon)Rabbi, physician and philosopher from Córdoba, later in Cairo1154–1191Shihāb al-Dīn SuhrawardīPersian founder of Illuminationism, executed in Aleppo1165–1240Ibn ʿArabīAndalusian mystic, called “the Greatest Master” by followers