Dialectica Open the atlas

China & East Asia · 1130–1200

Zhu Xi

Great synthesiser of Song Neo-Confucianism

Zhu Xi
向史公哲曰 · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Commons ↗

Systematised the theory of principle and qi and put the Four Books at the centre of learning; by investigating things patiently, one finally reaches a sudden, comprehensive understanding of principle.

Life and thought

Zhu Xi was born in 1130 in Fujian, passed the highest examination at eighteen, and found his direction under the teacher Li Tong. He preferred temple sinecures that left him time to teach and write, and rebuilt the White Deer Grotto Academy as a model school. His few years at court ended badly: in his last years his teaching was condemned as “false learning” and his followers purged, and he died in 1200 under that cloud. Within decades he was honoured, and from the 14th century until 1905 his commentaries on the Four Books were the basis of the civil service examinations.

Everything, he taught, is made of principle (li), what makes a thing what it is and how it ought to be, and qi, the vital stuff that gives it form and can be clear or turbid. Human nature is principle and therefore good; wrongdoing comes from turbid qi and selfish desire. The remedy is to “investigate things and extend knowledge”, studying the classics, history and the world while holding the mind in reverence, until one day understanding becomes comprehensive. His synthesis became orthodoxy in China, Korea, Japan and Vietnam.

Works

c. 1175Reflections on Things at Hand (with Lü Zuqian)
c. 1190Collected Commentaries on the Four Books

Shaped by

1033–1107Cheng YiYounger Cheng brother who made “principle” central1017–1073Zhou DunyiSong scholar honoured as the pioneer of Neo-Confucianism1020–1077Zhang ZaiNeo-Confucian who saw all things as condensations of qi

Shaped

1501–1570Yi Hwang (Toegye)Leading Neo-Confucian scholar of Joseon Korea1536–1584Yi I (Yulgok)Korean statesman-scholar and Toegye’s younger rival1895–1990Feng YoulanHistorian of Chinese philosophy and builder of a “new principle learning”

Criticised by

1139–1193Lu Jiuyuan (Lu Xiangshan)They debated method at Goose Lake Temple in 1175: Zhu’s broad study against Lu’s “simple and easy” return to the mind.1472–1529Wang YangmingWang first tried Zhu’s method by contemplating bamboo for days, fell ill, and later rejected the search for principle in things.

Meanwhile, in other traditions

1079–1142Peter AbelardParis logician famed for his dialectic and his love for Héloïsec. 1105–1185Ibn ṬufaylAndalusian court physician and philosophical novelist1126–1198Ibn Rushd (Averroes)Córdoban judge, known in Europe simply as “the Commentator”1138–1204Maimonides (Moses ben Maimon)Rabbi, physician and philosopher from Córdoba, later in Cairo1154–1191Shihāb al-Dīn SuhrawardīPersian founder of Illuminationism, executed in Aleppo1165–1240Ibn ʿArabīAndalusian mystic, called “the Greatest Master” by followers