Dialectica Open the atlas

Analytic & pragmatist · 1889–1951

Ludwig Wittgenstein

Viennese-born Cambridge philosopher who overturned his own first philosophy

Ludwig Wittgenstein
Moritz Nähr · Public domain · Commons ↗

Early: a sentence pictures a possible fact, and what cannot be said must be passed over in silence. Late: meaning is use within “language-games” woven into forms of life, and philosophy is therapy for the bewitchment of our intelligence by language.

Life and thought

Ludwig Wittgenstein (1889–1951) was born into one of the richest families in Vienna and trained as an engineer before Frege sent him to Russell at Cambridge in 1911. He wrote the Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus during the First World War, partly as a soldier and prisoner of war; believing he had solved philosophy’s problems, he gave away his fortune and taught in Austrian village schools. He returned to Cambridge in 1929 and held its chair of philosophy from 1939 to 1947.

The Tractatus holds that a sentence is a picture of a possible fact; what cannot be pictured, including ethics and the meaning of life, cannot be said, only shown. His later work, published after his death as Philosophical Investigations (1953), rejects that picture. Words do not get their meaning by naming objects; they work like tools in “language-games” woven into human activities, and for most words the meaning is the use. Many philosophical problems arise when language “goes on holiday”; the task of philosophy is to show the fly the way out of the fly-bottle.

Works

1921Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus
1953Philosophical Investigations (posthumous)

Teachers

1872–1970Bertrand RussellWittgenstein studied with Russell at Cambridge from 1911; within two years Russell felt the pupil had surpassed him.

Shaped by

1848–1925Gottlob FregeWittgenstein visited Frege in Jena, and it was Frege who advised him to go to Russell.1788–1860Arthur SchopenhauerGerman pessimist who saw a blind will behind all things

Students

1919–2001G. E. M. AnscombeAnscombe was Wittgenstein’s student, translated Philosophical Investigations and was one of his literary executors.

Shaped

1924–1998Jean-François LyotardThe Postmodern Condition borrows Wittgenstein’s “language games”.1931–2007Richard RortyNeopragmatist who challenged philosophy’s claim to mirror reality1882–1936Moritz SchlickFrom 1927 Schlick met Wittgenstein regularly, and treated the Tractatus as the Circle’s guiding text.1900–1976Gilbert RyleOxford philosopher who mocked the “ghost in the machine”

Argued against

354–430Augustine of HippoPhilosophical Investigations opens by quoting Augustine’s picture of learning words by naming objects, and then dismantles it.

Meanwhile, in other traditions

1885–1962Tanabe HajimeKyoto School philosopher and Nishida’s critic1889–1976Martin HeideggerGerman philosopher of Being, compromised by his Nazi party membership1891–1962Hu ShiMay Fourth reformer who brought pragmatism to China1891–1956B. R. AmbedkarDalit leader, jurist and chief architect of India’s constitution1891–1937Antonio GramsciItalian communist leader who wrote his major work in Mussolini’s prisons1892–1940Walter BenjaminBerlin critic who joined Marxism, messianism and media theory