Dialectica Open the atlas

China & East Asia · 1891–1962

Hu Shi

May Fourth reformer who brought pragmatism to China

A student of John Dewey at Columbia, he preached “bold hypotheses, careful verification”, applied scientific method to the study of Chinese tradition, and championed writing in the vernacular.

Life and thought

Hu Shi was born in Shanghai in 1891 to a family from Jixi, Anhui. A Boxer Indemnity scholarship took him to Cornell and then Columbia, where he studied under John Dewey and finished his dissertation in 1917 (the degree came in 1927). At Peking University he called for literature in the vernacular and became a leading voice of the New Culture and May Fourth movements, interpreting for Dewey on his 1919–21 tour. He was later ambassador to the United States, president of Peking University and head of the Academia Sinica in Taiwan, where he died in 1962.

He took from Dewey the view that ideas are tools for solving problems and must be tested by their consequences, and summed up method as “bold hypotheses, careful verification”. He urged “more study of problems, less talk of isms”, against grand ideological solutions. He turned critical method on China’s past: his Outline of the History of Chinese Philosophy began with Laozi and Confucius, not legendary sage kings, and his 1926 discovery of Shenhui manuscripts from Dunhuang rewrote the history of Chan.

Works

1917Some Modest Proposals for the Reform of Literature
1919Outline of the History of Chinese Philosophy, vol. 1

Teachers

1859–1952John DeweyHu Shi studied with Dewey at Columbia and interpreted for him during his lecture tour of China in 1919–21.

Argued against

1893–1988Liang ShumingHu Shi published a sharp review of Liang’s Eastern and Western Cultures and Their Philosophies.

Meanwhile, in other traditions

1889–1976Martin HeideggerGerman philosopher of Being, compromised by his Nazi party membership1889–1951Ludwig WittgensteinViennese-born Cambridge philosopher who overturned his own first philosophy1891–1956B. R. AmbedkarDalit leader, jurist and chief architect of India’s constitution1891–1937Antonio GramsciItalian communist leader who wrote his major work in Mussolini’s prisons1891–1970Rudolf CarnapVienna Circle’s great system-builder, later in Chicago and Los Angeles1892–1940Walter BenjaminBerlin critic who joined Marxism, messianism and media theory