Dialectica Open the atlas

Early modern Europe · 1712–1778

Jean-Jacques Rousseau

Geneva-born writer who blamed society, not nature, for human corruption

Jean-Jacques Rousseau
Maurice Quentin de La Tour (Life time: 1788) · Public domain · Commons ↗

In the state of nature humans were not warlike but free and capable of pity; inequality grew with property and society. Legitimate authority comes from the “general will” of citizens who give the laws to themselves.

Life and thought

Jean-Jacques Rousseau was born in Geneva; his mother died days after his birth, and at fifteen he left the city to wander as an apprentice, servant, music copyist and protégé of Madame de Warens. In Paris he befriended Diderot, and in 1750 he won fame with a prize essay arguing that the arts and sciences had corrupted morals. The Social Contract and Emile (both 1762) were condemned in Paris and Geneva, and he spent years in flight, quarrelling with former friends.

Rousseau turned the contract tradition around. In the Discourse on Inequality, natural human beings are solitary and peaceable, moved by self-love and pity; vanity, dependence and inequality arrive with society and property — the first man who fenced off a piece of land and said “this is mine” began the trouble. The Social Contract asks how people can live under law and still be free: by each giving themselves to a community ruled by the general will, so that in obeying the law they obey themselves. His ideas fed the French Revolution, Kant’s ethics of autonomy and modern theories of education.

Works

1755Discourse on the Origin of Inequality
1762The Social Contract
1762Emile, or On Education

Shaped by

1632–1704John LockeEnglish physician and philosopher of experience, consent and toleration

Shaped

1724–1804Immanuel KantKant wrote that Rousseau “set me right” and taught him to honour human beings.1908–2009Claude Lévi-StraussHe hailed Rousseau as the founder of the sciences of man.1921–2002John RawlsHarvard philosopher who revived political philosophy with justice as fairness

Argued against

1588–1679Thomas HobbesRousseau argued that Hobbes had projected the vices of society back onto natural man.1694–1778VoltaireRousseau’s 1756 letter on providence answered Voltaire’s poem on the Lisbon earthquake, beginning a lasting enmity.

Criticised by

1759–1797Mary WollstonecraftShe attacked Rousseau’s Emile for educating girls only to please men.

Meanwhile, in other traditions

1768–1834Friedrich SchleiermacherBerlin theologian and translator of Plato, father of modern hermeneutics