Dialectica Open the atlas

Early modern Europe · 1762–1814

Johann Gottlieb Fichte

German idealist who grounded all knowledge in the self’s activity

Kant’s thing in itself must go: philosophy should start from the I that “posits” itself and, in striving, posits a world that resists it. His Addresses to the German Nation (1808) made him a voice of German nationalism.

Life and thought

Johann Gottlieb Fichte was the son of a poor ribbon-weaver in Saxony; a local nobleman, impressed by the boy, paid for his schooling. His first book, Attempt at a Critique of All Revelation (1792), appeared anonymously and was at first taken for Kant’s, which made him famous overnight. He taught at Jena until the “atheism dispute” forced him out in 1799, then moved to Berlin, where he gave his Addresses to the German Nation (1807–08) under French occupation. He died in 1814 of typhus caught from his wife, who had been nursing soldiers.

Fichte thought Kant’s “thing in itself” — an unknowable cause of our sensations — made no sense. Philosophy should begin instead from the activity of the self: the I posits itself, and in order to act it must also posit something that resists it, the not-I. The world exists as the arena of our moral striving; freedom comes first. He rewrote his Science of Knowledge many times. Politically he moved from defending the French Revolution to German nationalism. His self-positing subject opened the way for Schelling and Hegel.

Works

1794Foundations of the Entire Science of Knowledge
1808Addresses to the German Nation

Shaped by

1724–1804Immanuel KantFichte’s first book (1792), published anonymously, was at first taken to be Kant’s own.

Shaped

1775–1854Friedrich Wilhelm Joseph SchellingGerman idealist philosopher of nature, art and freedom

Criticised by

1770–1831Georg Wilhelm Friedrich HegelHegel’s 1801 essay on the difference between Fichte’s and Schelling’s systems judged Fichte’s one-sidedly subjective.1788–1860Arthur SchopenhauerHe attended Fichte’s lectures in Berlin and came away contemptuous.

Meanwhile, in other traditions

1768–1834Friedrich SchleiermacherBerlin theologian and translator of Plato, father of modern hermeneutics1813–1855Søren KierkegaardDanish Christian thinker of the anxious, choosing individual