Dialectica Open the atlas

India · c. 5th c. BCE – today

Early Buddhism & Abhidharma

Suffering comes from craving rooted in ignorance of impermanence and non-self, and it can be ended by following the Eightfold Path.

The question

Why do we suffer, and how can suffering end?

Why it arose

Siddhārtha Gautama joined the śramaṇa wanderers, tried and rejected both a comfortable life and extreme austerity, and taught a ‘middle way’. After his death his discourses were memorised and later written down; Abhidharma scholars then systematised them into analyses of momentary physical and mental events (dharmas).

The reasoning

Everything we might call ‘me’—body, feeling, perception, mental formations, consciousness—is impermanent and conditioned, so none of it is a lasting self. Clinging to what cannot last produces suffering; remove the craving through ethics, meditation and insight, and the suffering it feeds ceases (nirvāṇa).

Key claims
  1. Four Noble Truths: suffering, its cause, its cessation, the path.
  2. No permanent self underlies the five aggregates.
  3. All conditioned things arise dependently and pass away.
What it left

Buddhism spread across Asia and gave rise to Madhyamaka, Yogācāra and the East Asian schools; its analysis of the self is now discussed alongside Hume and contemporary philosophy of mind.

Mind & selfEthicsMetaphysics

Thinkers

c. 480–400 BCE (debated; an older dating is c. 563–483 BCE)The Buddha (Siddhārtha Gautama)Founder of Buddhism, who taught a middle way out of sufferingfl. 5th c. CEBuddhaghosaTheravāda commentator who systematised doctrine in Sri Lanka

Key texts

c. 250 BCEDhammapada (verses attributed to the Buddha)The Buddha (Siddhārtha Gautama)
c. 430 CEVisuddhimagga (The Path of Purification)Buddhaghosa

Where it came from

Reacted against
Vedic & Upanishadic thoughtThe Buddha kept karma and rebirth but denied the permanent ātman that the Upanishads identified with Brahman.

What it led to

Carried on by
MadhyamakaNāgārjuna radicalised the Buddha’s dependent origination and non-self, turning them against the Abhidharma belief that the basic elements have their own nature.
Carried on by
YogācāraYogācāra pushed the Abhidharma analysis of mind further, concluding that experience can be explained by consciousness alone.
Opposed by
MīmāṃsāKumārila defended Vedic authority and a lasting self against Buddhist critics, and denied that the Buddha or anyone could be omniscient.

Its answers to the big questions

MetaphysicsWhat is ultimately real?No permanent substances at all: everything arises dependently and passes away.EthicsHow should one live?Follow the Eightfold Path and end the craving that causes suffering.Mind & selfWhat is the self?No self (anattā): a changing stream of five aggregates, with no owner behind them.God & the ultimateIs there a ground of everything?No creator. Speculating about first beginnings does not lead to liberation.