Dialectica Open the atlas

India · c. 480–540

Dignāga

Founder of Buddhist logic and epistemology

He cut the means of knowledge to perception and inference, defined perception as free of concepts, explained word meaning as exclusion (apoha), and mapped valid and invalid reasons in his ‘wheel of reasons’.

Life and thought

Dignāga (c. 480–540), born near Kāñcī in southern India, founded the Buddhist school of logic and epistemology (pramāṇa). Tradition, perhaps reliably, makes him a pupil of Vasubandhu. He spent his life debating at the monastic centres of his day and summed up his thought in the Compendium of Valid Cognition, which survives complete only in Tibetan translation.

Dignāga asked what the reliable means of knowledge are, and answered: only two, because there are only two kinds of object. Perception grasps unique, momentary particulars and is free of concepts; inference grasps general features through concepts. Everything else counts as one of these. Words, he argued, do not refer to real universals such as “cowness”; a word like “cow” works by excluding what is not-cow (apoha). In his “wheel of reasons” he tabulated which patterns of a reason’s presence and absence make an inference valid. Nyāya and Mīmāṃsā authors spent centuries answering him; Dharmakīrti refined his system.

Works

c. 520 CEPramāṇasamuccaya (Compendium of Valid Cognition)
c. 500 CENyāyamukha (Introduction to Logic)

Shaped by

c. 4th–5th c. CEVasubandhuTradition makes Dignāga a pupil of Vasubandhu; whether they actually met is uncertain.

Shaped

c. 600–660 (some scholars: mid-6th century)DharmakīrtiBuddhist logician whose theory of knowledge dominated Indian debate

Argued against

c. 2nd c. BCE – 2nd c. CE (traditional author)Akṣapāda GautamaDignāga rejected Nyāya’s four means of knowledge and its account of perception.

Criticised by

fl. c. 660Kumārila BhaṭṭaKumārila attacked Dignāga’s theory that words mean by exclusion (apoha).fl. c. 800 (estimates range from 725 to 840)Jayarāśi BhaṭṭaHis scepticism targets the Buddhist definitions of valid knowledge as well.

Meanwhile, in other traditions

412–485ProclusHead of the Platonic school in Athens and Neoplatonism’s great systematiserc. 477–524 or 526BoethiusRoman statesman who translated Aristotle’s logic into Latin