Dialectica Open the atlas

Continental · born 1956 · living

Judith Butler

American philosopher at Berkeley, theorist of gender performativity

Butler argued that gender is not an inner essence that behaviour expresses but a performance repeated under social norms, which produces the appearance of a natural sex; norms can be subverted by repeating them differently.

Life and thought

Judith Butler (born 1956) grew up in a Jewish family in Cleveland, studied philosophy at Yale and wrote a doctorate on the reception of Hegel in twentieth-century France. Gender Trouble (1990) made Butler one of the most widely cited theorists of the late twentieth century. After teaching at Johns Hopkins, Butler moved to the University of California, Berkeley, and has also written on violence, mourning, Jewish ethics and the politics of protest.

Butler asks whether gender is something we are or something we do. Gender Trouble argues that there is no inner gender identity that our behaviour expresses; gender is performative, produced by repeated acts, gestures and styles under social norms, and the repetition creates the appearance of a natural core, even of a natural binary of sex. Because norms must be repeated constantly, they can be repeated differently: drag, for example, exposes gender as imitation. Bodies That Matter answered critics by asking how norms shape what counts as a body. The work became foundational for queer theory and remains contested.

Works

1990Gender Trouble
1993Bodies That Matter

Shaped by

1926–1984Michel FoucaultFrench historian of madness, prisons and sexuality1930–2004Jacques DerridaAlgerian-born French philosopher who founded deconstruction1911–1960J. L. Austin“Performativity” adapts Austin’s performative utterances, read through Derrida.1908–1986Simone de BeauvoirButler started from Beauvoir’s “becomes a woman”, then questioned her split between sex and gender.

Meanwhile, in other traditions

born 1937Thomas NagelNYU philosopher who asked what it is like to be a bat1938–2002Robert NozickHarvard libertarian who answered Rawls1942–2024Daniel DennettTufts philosopher who explained consciousness as the brain’s workborn 1946Peter SingerAustralian utilitarian of animal liberation and effective givingborn 1947Martha NussbaumChicago philosopher of the capabilities approach and the emotionsborn 1966David ChalmersAustralian philosopher who named the “hard problem” of consciousness